20+ Best Thanksgiving Pie Recipes (2024)

What are the best pies?

Pies have long been a cornerstone of family gatherings, particularly during festive seasons like Thanksgiving and Christmas.

The tradition of including pies in these celebrations is deeply rooted in history. For example, while pumpkin pie is synonymous with Thanksgiving, it wasn’t the earliest pie on record. That distinction goes to pecan pie, dating back to the 1920s.

Christmas pies, often adorned with festive decorations, owe their origins to religious practices, with fish-based pies emerging as popular options during meat-free days mandated by the church.

As you delve into the rich tapestry of pie history, you might wonder about the most cherished pies around the world. Here’s a glimpse into some globally acclaimed varieties:

Cream Pie: Features a crisp crust and a luscious creamy filling, crowned with a layer of whipped cream.

Meat Pie: A beloved Australian dish, comprising a flaky pastry shell filled with gravy and minced meat.

Key Lime Pie: A delightful blend of tart key lime juice, sweetened condensed milk, and eggs, forming a delectable custard.

Pecan Pie: Combines a slender pastry base with a rich blend of eggs, butter, flour, sweeteners, and chopped pecans.

Pumpkin Pie: An American Thanksgiving classic, this pumpkin custard pie is seasoned with spices like cinnamon and nutmeg, often served with whipped cream.

Pot Pie: A savory delight, brimming with meat and vegetables, encased in pastry.

Apple Pie: A golden crust envelops cinnamon-sugar coated apples, creating a timeless favorite.

Other renowned pies for dessert table include mud pie, banana cream pie, buttermilk pie, coconut cream pie, mince pie, blueberry pie, cranberry pie, custard pie, pear pie, and caramel apple pie recipe.

What is the most popular pie in America?

Pie holds a special place in American culinary culture, enjoyed throughout the year and indispensable during holiday feasts. Insider‘s poll from November 16-17, 2019, shed light on America’s top five favorite pies: apple, pumpkin, pecan, chocolate cream, and cherry.

See alsoDelicious Sweet Cherry Recipes.

Apple pie emerged as the beloved choice, epitomizing the classic American dessert experience.

Creative pie recipes

If you’re seeking novel and delightful pie recipes for the upcoming Thanksgiving and Christmas season, here’s a curated list of 21 unique yet simple-to-make pie recipes, guaranteed to add a touch of creativity to your holiday feasts.

21.Paleo Apple Pie Crumb Bars – Delicious Thanksgiving Dessert

Delight in the essence of autumn with these wholesome Paleo Apple Pie Crumb Bars, a treat that melds a sumptuous, buttery shortbread base with tangy apples, crowned with a crunchy, nut-infused topping. Ideal for festive gatherings!

Experience a twist on the classic apple pie with these Paleo Apple Pie Crumb Bars. Picture layers of golden, caramel-kissed apples nestled on a luscious shortbread foundation, all topped with a delectable, crumbly streusel.

Crafted to be gluten-free, dairy-free, and vegan-friendly!

Whip up this swift and straightforward dessert in under an hour, making it the perfect quick indulgence for any occasion.

20. The Best Keto Low Carb and Vegan Pumpkin Pie for Thanksgiving Dinner

Indulge in a sumptuous Keto and Low Carb Pumpkin Pie, a holiday must-have with its velvety, rich texture. Ideal for festive celebrations, it’s even more divine when topped with a generous dollop of whipped cream!

Presenting the ultimate Keto-friendly Pumpkin Pie, featuring a coconut flour crust, making it a superb sugar-free option for your Thanksgiving feast.

Savor the creamy delight of this pie, a perfect match for those on a low carb diet, while still embracing the festive spirit. The pumpkin shines as the star ingredient, promising a recipe that will become a cherished tradition year after year. It’s so delicious, even those not following a low carb diet will be enamored!

19.Keto Cauliflower Cheese Pie for Holiday Table

Behold the Keto Cauliflower Cheese Pie, a culinary masterpiece that’s golden and crisp on the exterior while remaining tender and juicy inside. With just four key ingredients, this pie has become my staple for any meal, be it breakfast, lunch, or dinner.

It’s a hit in my household, especially with my daughter who adores cauliflower-based dishes. This recipe has captured her heart, and I highly recommend it for anyone mindful of their health. Simple and straightforward, this cauliflower cheese pie is a breeze to prepare.

18.Easy Mini Apple Pies for Thanksgiving Day

Experience the charm of these Easy Mini Apple Pies, a timeless dessert that delights with its warmth and sweetness. Crafted in a muffin tin, they boast a buttery, flaky puff pastry shell brimming with a lusciously gooey apple filling.

Each pie is adorned with a decorative top, adding to their allure. The enchanting aroma of apple spice that wafts from these pies is simply irresistible. For the ultimate indulgence, serve them fresh and warm, straight from the oven.

17. Classic Sweet Potato Pie Recipe

Embrace the essence of festive gatherings with this Classic Sweet Potato Pie, a delightful dessert for both Thanksgiving and Christmas. Made with condensed milk, it offers a subtly sweet taste. Here’s a guide to crafting this treat in your own kitchen.

A staple in Southern culinary tradition, sweet potato pie is a perfect addition to any holiday dessert spread. Its year-round availability makes it an excellent choice for a cozy afternoon snack, ideally paired with coffee or tea.

16. Bourbon Chocolate Pecan Pie – Make a Thanksgiving Pie!

Get ready to indulge in a pie that combines an exquisite trio of flavors: bourbon, chocolate, and pecans. This recipe uses dark chocolate chips to create a rich taste, but milk chocolate chips are a great alternative for those who prefer a milder flavor.

Drawing inspiration from Derby Pie and the classic Thanksgiving pecan pie, our Bourbon Chocolate Pecan Pie recipe is a showstopper, sure to captivate your taste buds.

15.Peanut Butter Pudding Pie Filling With Meringue

After my journey to Lubbock, Texas for the Peanut Tour, my fascination with peanuts and peanut butter has reached new heights! Regular readers of this blog know of my passion for crafting homemade puddings, including chocolate, pumpkin, and hot chocolate varieties.

Now, I’m excited to share a delightful Peanut Butter Pudding Pie with Meringue, blending my love for peanuts with the art of pudding-making.

14. Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie

For those who adore the combination of chocolate and peanut butter, this Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie is a dream dessert. It features layers of crunchy graham cracker, smooth peanut butter filling, and rich chocolate, creating a heavenly treat.

13. Chocolate Covered Pretzel Cream Pie

Indulge in the luxurious Chocolate Covered Pretzel Cream Pie, where the richness of chocolate custard filling meets the unique taste of a crushed pretzel crust.

Topped with fresh whipped cream, this chocolate pie offers a perfect balance of sweet and salty flavors, making it an irresistible dessert choice.

12.Grain Free Fig And Walnut Tart

Embrace the transition from summer to autumn with this delightful Grain-Free Fig and Walnut Tart. It’s a perfect seasonal recipe that combines the natural sweetness of figs with the rich texture of walnuts, all in a grain-free delight.

+

11. Gluten-Free Cherry Pie

Discover the joy of this Gluten-Free Cherry Pie, featuring a delicate, flaky crust enveloped around a zesty cherry filling.

This vibrant and tasty pie is an excellent addition to any holiday table and is beloved throughout the year. It’s a popular choice for those who favor gluten-free desserts without compromising on taste.

10. English Banoffee Pie

Banoffee Pie, a renowned dessert from England, is a must-try for its simplicity and exquisite flavors.

This no-bake pie is composed of layers that start with a crunchy graham cracker crust, followed by rich toffee, fresh sliced bananas, and is crowned with a layer of whipped cream.

This dessert is a delightful treat that perfectly captures the essence of English confectionery.

9.No-Bake Strawberry Jello Pie

Indulge in the simplicity and deliciousness of this No-Bake Strawberry Jello Pie. Crafted with ease, it incorporates a ready-made graham cracker crust, fluffy Cool Whip, ripe strawberries, and, of course, Strawberry Jell-O.

This pie is a delightful treat that combines convenience with classic flavors.

8.Easy No-Bake Peanut Butter Pie

Experience the sheer delight of this Easy No-Bake Peanut Butter Pie, a dessert that’s perfect for any season. Its simplicity and exquisite taste make it an ideal choice for those who love the rich flavor of peanut butter in a fuss-free, delicious dessert.

7.Frozen Lemonade Pie

This Frozen Lemonade Pie recipe comes with a special nod to Eagle Brand. As a sponsored creation, my genuine affection and preference for this brand shine through in this refreshing, tangy, and sweet dessert, perfect for any occasion.

6. Gluten-Free Dark Cherry Lemon Pie

Savor the unique blend of flavors in this Gluten-Free Dark Cherry Lemon Pie. It strikes a delightful balance between sweetness and tartness, with a subtle hint of lemon zest that brightens and freshens the taste.

This pie is a perfect choice for those who love a zesty twist in their desserts.

5.Cherry Crumble Pie

Cherry Crumble Pie stands out as both a seasonal favorite and a straightforward recipe to perfect. Many would argue that the most exquisite cherry pies are those that emerge from the kitchens of our grandmothers, infused with love and traditional charm.

4.Easy Classic Key Lime Pie

Discover the joy of making an Easy Classic Key Lime Pie, a recipe that offers a creamy and refreshing taste, bursting with the vibrant flavor of fresh key limes. This pie is a delightful treat, simple to make, yet rich in taste and texture.

3. Lemon Pie with Sugar Cookie Crust

Bask in the essence of summer with this Lemon Pie featuring a Sugar Cookie Crust.

This ultimate summer pie recipe is not only delightful in flavor but also convenient, as you can prepare it in advance. Be ready to impress when it’s dessert time with this zesty and sweet treat.

2. Easy Chocolate Mousse Favorite Pie for your Thanksgiving Table

Elevate your Thanksgiving dessert spread with this Easy Chocolate Mousse Pie. It’s a crowd-pleaser that’s simple to make and absolutely delicious.

Featuring a no-bake approach and anOREO cookie crust, this chocolate mousse pie is a fun and indulgent treat that’s perfect for chocolate lovers and a hit with the whole family.

1.Rhubarb Pie with Crumble Topping – Best Thanksgiving Pie Recipe!

Introducing the Rhubarb Pie with Crumble Topping, a stellar Thanksgiving and spring dessert and a top pick for Thanksgiving.

The pie beautifully balances the sweetened rhubarb, which loses its tartness upon baking, with a brown sugar and oatmeal crumble topping. Serve this easy-to-make rhubarb pie either warm or cold, and pair it with a scoop of vanilla ice cream for a truly irresistible treat.